Yes, but then again he was mean when he let Bella talk about their marriage when Jacob was just around. Isn't it?
And I think that Anne-Elizabeth has a good plot, but the ending... DIFFERENT! Jacob can't die! Not just because I'm Team Jacob, but there are also Team Edward members who like him even if it's just for a bit.
Edward is jealous but he wouldn't try to suicide, cause that wouldn't be good for Bella, that wouldn't make her happy, and Edward wants the best for Bella, even thought she'd be with another....
Mud pies come from Rosenberg. In the original story Bella met Jacob later than Edward.
Uh. Do you really believe Jacob would go to kill himself??