Please explain this to me. Why do you want Bella to pick Jacob? If she was to chose him and not Edward, there will be no Renesmee for Jacob to imprint on. The way I understand it is that imprinting is more powerful than the love you have for someone ( ex. Sam, Leah and Emily). Plus you cannot control who you imprint on. Once again, if she was to chose Jacob and someone else came along that he was to imprint with, then Bella would have no one.