Do you want the Movie of New Moon to be based on the book?

I really want the Movie of Twilight Saga New Moon to be based on the book because in Twilight movie many of the scene in the book is not show in the movie.. I'm a bit of disappointed because some part change but I also like it...

0 members like this

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by yuval sadde on September 6, 2009 at 8:49am

Yeah! The book is always different from the movies! Even at New Moon it's not the same!!

Permalink Reply by aLyanNa on September 12, 2009 at 8:21am

yes , i really want to ..
i was disappointed when they cut really good scenes from the book in twilight ..

Permalink Reply by Fran on September 12, 2009 at 12:28pm

I would love it if New Moon was based more on the book, but I know I will be disappointed with movie...I have the nasty habit of reading the books first then watching the movie, so with that said I wont watch in the theaters I will wait for the DVD so I can sit at home at scream at the TV.

Permalink Reply by Team Switzerland on September 13, 2009 at 3:47pm

Yes i want New moon to be based on the book because i hated the Twilight movie it was so off the book im glad Catherine is not the directer not that I dont like her she is good at directing, but not at directing movies that r based on books because she added scenes that where never in the book and the scenes I wanted in the book she didnt put in and come on if its a book related movie its easier because u already have a script written but she had to change the script i loved the diologue of twilight so it got me mad when she changed it like,........... the field trip THAT NEVER HAPPENED and Jacob in the beggining of the movie THAT NEVER HAPPENED EITHER!!!

Permalink Reply by Jennifer on September 15, 2009 at 10:24am

are you serious that catherine is not the director of new moon?? i never knew that

Permalink Reply by Jennifer on September 15, 2009 at 10:23am

i really really really want the movie to be based on the book because ur right, in twilight they missed out a lot...
but looking at the extended trailer they got many of the book in it! so fingerscrossed

Permalink Reply by Michael Devon on September 15, 2009 at 9:09pm

We should all know that any movie based on a book is always different than the book. If they made the movie exactly like the book, it would be too long of a movie. Now I understand Twilight fans would love that, but many casual fans wouldn't. Unfortunatly, its all about the money. Hopefully, New Moon will be better, but it wont be exact.

Permalink Reply by Jazmine Rose on September 16, 2009 at 1:40am

All the movies are based on the book....?
Its not going to an exact replica.. kinda hard to add every single detail.
Plus its going to have differences. Either way it will be awesome! Stephanie Meyer is behind all the production so I'm sure she wont let us down.
As for Twilight .. It's a really good movie, but it was low budget, so it won't be as good as the rest of the saga since they have so much money now and can afford every kind of effect.

Permalink Reply by Madeline Elise on September 16, 2009 at 1:41pm

thats true

Permalink Reply by Madeline Elise on September 16, 2009 at 1:40pm

me to, the more i see the movie the more i see how far from it is from the book, i don't like the movie that much, plus the whole time im yelling at the TV saying "thats not what happpened"..or " they should take out the dumb field trip part and put in 'blood type". can't wait to see it though !!

Permalink Reply by Taylor Cullen on September 17, 2009 at 10:31pm

they should make a 4 hour long movie if they have to to make it exactly like the book