Bree Tanner

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Malissa on June 7, 2010 at 8:59pm

I just finished it not 2 minutes ago...yeah, it was a bummer. I had wished when I read Eclipse that Jane would have spared her. Now I wish even more that she had. But what about Fred.....New book maybe???

Permalink Reply by Tara on June 8, 2010 at 3:38am

Someone could write a fanfic in which Bree is saved? idk..

Permalink Reply by Malissa on June 10, 2010 at 9:56am

LOL...well how else was it going to end? I mean once she was ripped apart and thrown on the pyre...her perspective was completely over.

Permalink Reply by Malissa on June 10, 2010 at 10:09pm

LOL, yeah, I know!

Permalink Reply by Monya on June 10, 2010 at 4:51pm

I finished the book last night and I was bummed that Bree got killed. I don't think she deserved that :-) I recon she would have done very well with the Cullens. Very sad indeed..

Permalink Reply by Nicole Cullen on June 10, 2010 at 10:40pm

I almost cried when i read the book...i cry easily..xD As soon as Diego didn't come back with Riley..i knew what happened...it was so sad for me. I also think that it was so unfair that she died since it wasn't her fault that she didn't know the rules. But i just can't picture her with the Cullens..so i liked the way it ended, but it was very sad of course. Great book Stephenie!

Permalink Reply by Alice.In.Cullenland on June 11, 2010 at 12:42am

Well, we already knew she was going to be killed, which somehow made it even sadder reading it.
For me, though, at least I didn't have that confliction I was dreading I'd have. The one where, after you get so attatched to these new characters that you don't want them to be hurt, yet you know the newborns all lose in the fighting so you're left wondering who kills them (aside from Bree, since we know how she died). I was worried that when Diego or Fred lost their fights in the clearing, I'd get scary-revengeful and be like 'What good-for-nothing jerk killed him?!' and then have it end up being Esme - then I'd feel terrible. So, admittedly, I'm kind of glad I didn't have to worry about that...

I do think it would have been interesting if Bree was kept alive, they could have helped her find Fred, but the story wouldn't have flowed right with this extra newborn vampire to take care of... It's really very sad.

Permalink Reply by Antonia hernandez on June 11, 2010 at 2:07am

Yeah I wish she could have realize Diego was dead sooner and went with Fred or could have stayed with the Cullen's or maybe the Danali Clan.Bree was cool really liked her very smart for 3months in a way.