New Moon Book or Movie?
I saw New Moon the day it came out, and personally i didn't like the movie as much as the book. I liked the movie but I thought the book had so much more description, but my freinds who disagree say, you can't SEE Edward or anyone in the book. So I was wondering what some other fans thought?!?!
Tags: Book, Book-or-Movie, Movie, New-Moon
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by palea lewis on -
well i havent seen the movie yet :{ its sold out here but i have read all the books and seen twilite as well as other book made into movies and the truth of the matter is the movie can never hold as much detail it would make it to long and difficult! But some times the movie ads a little extra and adds an explination to things the book looked over in order to add other details. So they kinda work hand in hand filling in each others missed over parts. Case in point interview with a vampire was great both book and movie and they each had a little more in some parts that others but all movies put faces with the charcters! Thats why i think they complament each other!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sounds like that is what your friends was trying to say as well!!!!
-
-
Permalink Reply by Kris Narjes on
-
I agree, I saw the movie on the second night I think the movie left out a lot of things I thought were important.. I think they did a better job with Twilight. Kris
-
-
Permalink Reply by Sarah Emm Cullen on -
Ya. I have read the book a few times and i don't remember them coming that close to kissing in Bella's kitchen.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Carine Tavares Branco on
-
The book is ALWAYS better!
-
-
Permalink Reply by Niki Froelich on -
New Moon was my least favorite of all four books. But I really liked the movie. I was never all that into Jacob, but I am very interested in Taylor.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Sarah Emm Cullen on
-
I know that a lot of people thought new moon was the least favorite but why? I liked new moon.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Isabella Marie Swan 9004 on -
The book was better then the movie. There are things in the book that are impossible to show on screen. I feel that way about most books that are made into movies. Considering the story I think the people that made the New Moon movie did a great job, not sure it could have been done any better. The scene in the book when Edward and Bella are back together, that night afterward and the morning. The entire experience at the Volturi, it's so much better in the book. But I don't think they would have been able to do all that in the movie because it would have been way too long.
-
-
Permalink Reply by jklly12 on -
Well I would have to say I liked both, but I liked the movie more. Reason's because the movie bella didn't allow jake to be all touchy feelly and in the last part told him don't make me choose becasue it will always be him.
-
-
Permalink Reply by esthie cullen on -
i think book more interesting than movie cz book take us imagination,
mu'up klo inggrize slah2an......... -
© 2013 Created by Hachette Book Group.
Report an Issue | Guidelines | Report an Issue | Terms of Service
