ROSALIE V.S JACOB

Who were you more mad at in BD. Rosalie because she didn't care if Bella died or Jacob for being such a jerk about the baby (Renesmee) and then ending up imprinting on her.

0 members like this

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by XO Edward XO Jacob XO on November 1, 2010 at 9:10pm

I wouldn't say I was mad at either... They both had there reasons... Rose didn't care either way live or die for Bella... She wasn't rooting for her to die though and Jacob didn't like Nessie because he didn't understand what the baby was and what it ment to Bella and himself... Jacob hated Nessie becasue he Loved Bella.

Permalink Reply by Candy Davenport on November 3, 2010 at 11:05am

i would have to agree with u even though I don't like that he imprinting on Nessie. I was hoping it was a vampire that came to witness or someone else I think it would have made it a lot less weird.

Permalink Reply by Athena Cullen on November 1, 2010 at 9:21pm

I was actually really mad at both. Rosalie didnt deserve bellas baby AT ALL cause she didnt care if bella lived or not yet jacob was being a total jerk about how the baby was killing bella and he just went on and on. well when he imprinted i was mad cause u cant just fall in love with some1 you hated so much. it doesnt work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Permalink Reply by Amanda Newlen on November 4, 2010 at 8:01pm

I completely agree with u! It makes me so angry that rosalie was so unconcerned about Bella just the baby and I really wish Bella got ahold of Jacob after she found out he imprinted on her baby why did Seth have to step in the way? Jacob is so Juevinille like going to Charlie just because he doesnt want them to leave with Renesmee Really how selfish!

Permalink Reply by XO Edward XO Jacob XO on November 1, 2010 at 10:05pm

He didn't no he was going to imprint on her... He didn't call her an IT after he imprinted on her

Permalink Reply by Lisa on November 1, 2010 at 9:41pm

Jacob only because I understood about Rosalie.

Permalink Reply by 파크 으니 혜 ♥park euni hye♥ on November 1, 2010 at 10:14pm

Its funny that im no longer mad at both^^..actually i find them hilarious at BD i understand them more and i think they were just victims of unwanted fate..lol we might just give different interpretations on these two..the imprinting is so funny to me..its like you pee on a place and you claims it your teritory^^

Permalink Reply by Kyleigh Elizabeth Nelson on November 1, 2010 at 11:56pm

I was mad at both. Rosealie was selfish and Jacob was awfull.

Permalink Reply by Smitha on November 2, 2010 at 12:58am

When you look closely at both the charecters,they both have a point to their fights. Rosalie has spent all life struggling to be a vampire,she wanted human experiences and so she supported Bella. On the other hand,Jacob loved Bella so he obviously hated Rosalie's attitude. He hated everything that hurt Bella. So,I wasnt mad at either one.

Permalink Reply by Alice.In.Cullenland on November 2, 2010 at 2:11am

The thing about Rosalie is that I honestly don't feel she would accept anything if she wouldn't do it herself. So regarding Bella's death, Rosalie was accepting that Bella's life was over for this child, as Rosalie believed it was right that this child be born--and she, herself, would accept her fate if she were in Bella's place, for the baby. As XOEdwardXO said, she wasn't rooting for Bella to die. And, then, the fact that having a child--Rosalie's most desired wish that she's spent her entire vampire existence pained and broken over--could still come true by some miracle (even if it wasn't her child, it was still a child of their family)... If a dream that you never thought you would ever have a chance at having again was just inches from your grasp, it would make you a little desperate, and, in the process, a little selfish.

As for Jacob, all he knew was the girl he loved was dying because of the half-vampire baby inside her. The 'thing' in her was unheard of and the only information they had on it was that it was hurting Bella and killing her--those usually aren't signs of something good. Even Edward called Renesmee "it" before he understood everything; they were being driven by fear, anger, and frustration. It's understandable. The imprinting thing between Jacob and Renesmee...I really don't like, but Jacob had no control over it. You can hate the fact he imprinted (like I do), but you can't hate the poor boy for something he didn't choose.

Both had more to their story, so I wasn't mad at either. A little annoyed at some parts, certainly; but not mad.

Permalink Reply by Irmasencullens on November 3, 2010 at 11:56am

@ Hypnotize, I agree with you sista.. It just like misunderstanding. I myself kinda like with Rosalie caracter,she's like that only because she wanted something but sadly she would never have it. She,in my view,also doesnt want Bella die, she care for Bella too,but Rosalie is Rosalie,she doesnt want look fragile infront of people.

As for Jacob,another misunderstanding here. Yeah, Jacob wanted to kill the 'thing' too when 'it' still inside Bella because he think 'the thing' only make Bella pain and Jacob can stand it!!! But yeah, the imprinting thing is really weird, and sadly,Jacob imprinting to Renesmee...