Why do you think everybody doesn't like Rose?

Really, I dont understand. She is great !!! WHY really WHY everybody thinks that she is so selfish or mean???? Tell me what do you think !!

0 members like this

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Johanna L on December 30, 2009 at 2:31pm

I think she didn't like Bella because she was putting her only family at risk, and she doesn't want to lose her family. I understand Rosalie's point of view.

Permalink Reply by ღbєℓℓα mαяìє ƨωαηღ on December 30, 2009 at 11:32pm

becasue she is against bella.

Permalink Reply by Kaitlyn Michelle on January 4, 2010 at 4:19pm

I think everybody doesn't like her because of how she treats Bella and Edward. They feel she is being unfair to Bella even though we later find out she is mostly justified.

Permalink Reply by kelsey on January 17, 2010 at 1:00am

i like hershe reminds me of my sis.lol

Permalink Reply by Rosalie Lillian Hale Cullen on January 21, 2010 at 7:07pm

I agree with all of you guys, I love Rose she's amazing!!!:)
XoXo Rosalie

Permalink Reply by Oyana Miller on January 21, 2010 at 9:34pm

i think she was mean but now tht i know her story i know
why she acts that way.

Permalink Reply by Rosalie Leah Cullen on January 29, 2010 at 9:00am

God! I can list more reasons than I would like too, so I guess here's a few:

1. People look at Edwards Description of Rosalie and how she is conceited, b****y, self-centered, vain, a brat, etc. And only see that side of her.....

2. Bella gets everything and I mean everything she wants. Rosalie just wants to have a family and kids, and she doesn't get that. Heck, Bella got all that, and Rose didn't! Wouldn't you be bitter, too?

3. I agree with everyone's comments.

4. Bella also contributes to that, because when Bella says something, she basically gets it......and Rosalie doesn't. Bella also thinks that she's conceited, a B****, self-centered, vain, etc.

5. If we, the Rosalie fans, could have our way, the whole book series of Twilight would be turned upside down and Rosalie, well, her past would be a lot more happier.....I think.

Please tell me if you agree! Thanks!

Permalink Reply by Cullenhalelover on February 23, 2010 at 10:27pm

The fact that the whole series is done in either Bella's POV or Jacob's is the main reason people hate on Rosalie. It takes intelligent readers to analyze the story and go deeper to find out about different characters. Not everyone is willing to read and think about the depth of all the characters. Reading in first person has that as a flaw.....you only get one perspective instead of a vast majority.

Permalink Reply by Amber Athene Chase on March 1, 2010 at 6:04pm

People don't like Rosalie because the story is told out of Bella's point of view and Bella makes Rosalie look like an evil person that doesn't have feelings for others.

Permalink Reply by Cullenhalelover on March 6, 2010 at 1:27pm

Great point and I totally agree. Plus Bella was completely intimidated by Rosalie's beauty and the fact that Edward had a chance to be with her when she was first turned so yea Bella isnt the best view point to go by when it comes to Rosalie.

Permalink Reply by escaily on May 3, 2010 at 6:53pm

well there is a draft SM made in rosalie's point of view somewhere in her site, when she made the phone call in new moon, when i read that i really think i befriended rosalie

lately i have been really found of misunderstood characters and rose is of the cullen family the one that is most.
i mean what would it feel for bella to be in her place, i know because i have.

what would it feel to have everything a woman wanted, eternal youth eternal beauty and let me say eternaly slim, you know rosalie has been that forever and i would die to ask bella what would it feel like to be every woman's dream but to be paying the price that rosalie paid?

yes she is pretty young and slim but she is miserable to, she would be willing to change all that for a chance being human, for her womb to be able to procreate and get fat with a baby,to be able to age pass her years and not be stuck as a eternal senior, to forget she is tied to be forever hungry for blood, rosalie would change anything, her beauty her youth, even emmett to turn the clock around

i think people dont see what it must feel like to be her, yes you have anything a woman would want, but not her she doesnt want it, maybe she did once upon a time when she was a spoiled banker's daughter, but now she is trapped in the mess, being steril is horrible, being a age less walking porcelain monster must be too, at her eyes, for her not to have a baby, i cant know what is must feel for rose when she sees human moms walk around her every day, while she is stuck being young forever, if in one thing rosalie could be considered selfish is in wanting the things that where taken away from her so i undertand perfectly why rosalie would have been the one to vote NO, yes i would vote no too