I am not sure why you are against Breaking Dawn? Could you explain a little more? I think it gives all the characters a happy ending!! Jacob has such a bond with Renesmee, he would never think she was a monster. I would love to discuss this with you further.
I agree with Renesmee's Mother:
Everyone has a happy ending which is ultimately what we all wish for!
Well... The first thing I thought of was: WHAT?!! HOW THE HECK WOULD YOU HATE BREAKING DAWN?!!!! But I ca understand your feelings. A little. I guess Jacob just gave up after Bella *died* (not really). And then he just coincidencially made an imprint on Renesmee. So yeah, maybe Jacob became a *good guy* (a little) after imprinting on Renesmee because he loves her so much now. And maybe Edward's family is just a little (okay a lot) overprotective about Bella because Edward's family really loves him so much so they don't want him to be all sad and lonely. So yeah, Bella's the lucky one to have such supernatural beings protecting her like she's a God. But I don't think that Renesmee is just trouble in the book.
Well, that's what I think.*smiles* No offense to anybody.;">
people are saying that jacob was in love with renesme because she was half of Bella. shouldn't Jacob have been in love with Edward too since both Edward and Bella made Renesme? and i thought werewolfs hate the scent of vampires. even if she is half a vampire, shouldn't they hate each other's scent or does tru luv make all that stuff go away?
I don't know what people are saying, however the author of the book explained it well enough: an imprinting is beyond the control of the one that is imprinted upon.
As for the scent issue, Renesmee is a hybrid, yes, but she is a creature with blood and a beating heart, not an ice cold creature with a body like marble. So who is to say she "stinks" like a vampire? That wouldn't even make sense, really.
I dont understand where your coming from.I think jacob was fine after imprinting on her actually. I think that he even matured a whole lot and may I ask. What do you have against Renesmee?
Because people give really stupid reasons of why they dislike her?
Im glad that everyone got a happy-ending.