Did Eclipse make Bella seem trapped?

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by RENESME CARLIE CULLEN on October 13, 2009 at 8:11pm

i never saw it that way ur right

Permalink Reply by XxX...sOriika...XxX on October 13, 2009 at 8:23pm

he is a huge overprotective fool!
He just wants to take care of Bella, he wants to see Bella the most safe as he can, so he worries to much, and Jacob is a temperamental person, so if he gets mad...
he can hurts Bella, so, Eddie, doesn't want that (Bella to see Jacob)

Permalink Reply by ▒☆✿Lucy◦Camui✿☆▒ on October 13, 2009 at 8:54pm

I agree, it never seemed to me that her relationship with Edward or friendship with Jacob was healthy in the first place. It seems kind of abusive from both parts, not physically.

Permalink Reply by GemmaJ on October 14, 2009 at 2:03pm

KiKi

I can see how it came across that way and i did see it slightly, but i aso see it as protection, Edward has never felt this way and he worries so much about her and he gets a little obsessive, but he does in the end and they agree on her seeing him. But he also did have experience with werewolves and hat was the other issue that he had with Jacob, he knows how unstable a new wolf is regardless if Jacob is brilliantly controlled or not would you send your other half to that.
Also think of the jealousy aspect, you want to meet up with a boy that is so obviously in love with your girlfriend i d be pretty jealous too.

Do get me wrong he is pretty extreme but the is reason to his madness

Gx

Permalink Reply by Fran on October 14, 2009 at 3:06pm

No I don't see it as Bella being trapped...Edward was just being very over protective of her...Bella understood it to a certain degree. She may not have liked it but she she did understand..Bella was a magnet for danger, Edward knew that. He didn't want to take any chances when it came to her safety. Edward loving Bella was very new to him, he had almost lost her once before, he wouldn't let it happen again..And as for paying Alice to babysit with a new car, she would have gotten it anyways..she loved Bella. Alice wanted Bella safe as well. So I would not say trapped.
Also another reason for Edward not wanting her around Jacob was the fact that Alice couldn't see the wolves, Bella just disappeared.That would freak me out a little bit too. Not knowing if she was o.k.

Permalink Reply by Sadie Phoenix Lavoie on October 15, 2009 at 12:29am

78844444444444444xzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz`n/bbbbb rooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooodf,c,f.x lol my kitten went on the keyboard umm well she wasnt trapped its just that he wanted her to 43444 be safe and that he didnt trust jacob then ... i would done the same if i was edward