who do you think had it harder in New Moon: Edward or Jacob?
Edward: who was forced to leave Bella and then believed that she was dead
or
Jacob: who slowly fell in love with Bella and ended up losing her
or
Jacob: who slowly fell in love with Bella and ended up losing her
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Kaxxandra on -
Who had it worse? Definitely Jacob! Poor guy completely gives his all & his all was not good enough to get the girl. Talk about a broken heart-to not have Bella reciprocate that love back.......you can't help but feel that ache with him.
Edward left & thus there were consequences. But in the end, he gets the girl! -
-
Permalink Reply by Pace Black on -
Edward wasn't forced to leave anyone, he just didn't weigh his options properly, that's his bad. Jacob doesn't really loose Bella, cause in Eclipse she admits she's in love with him. Go team Jacob!
-
-
Permalink Reply by Bellalicious(: on -
I Seriously Think That Edward Hard It Harder. When he found Bella, she was his life, she became the reason he was alive like many times he said to her. He could do anything for her, and his life had a meaning thanks to Bella. He was alone for so many years and when he finally found Bella he was forced to leave her because she thought she was in danger with him. From The Look Of His Eyes, This Was No Easy Task Leaving Her. But Eventually They Were Reunitedd. so yayy! thats all that matters noww. :)
-
-
Permalink Reply by Grace Stanley on -
I think they all had it hard, because Edward was already weary of the relationship that was developing between Jacob and Bella. So not only did he have worry about Bella being around wolves, but the threat of being killed by Jasper and possible someone else in his family that couldn't resist the smell of her blood. I also think that Jacob had a reality check of the bond between Edward and Bella was unbreakable and how far they would go for each other and how much they would endure to be with each other.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Robyn on -
After numerous reads of the series, I grew to so love Jake, and I am an Edward girl. I've seen the movie 3 x, and the last time, I cried for Jake's pain! He's such a real, genuine, warm, loving guy, and absolutely besotted with Bella. While Edward and Bella are soulmates, I can see how easy it would be to fall for Jake. I think they both went through incredible pain, but in the end, Jake's may be worse, because he doesn't get Bella, and it's so hard for him. I wonder, I may become Team Switzerland soon!!!
Naw, I love Edward too much! :-) -
-
Permalink Reply by Medley_00 on -
I have to say that it was Jacob who lost the most. He had fallen in love with Bella and his heart was completely hers. Edward made the choice to leave Bella, so his hurt was self inflicted.
Don't get me wrong I am a Total Edward fan and love him to death, both his character and him in real life! -
-
Permalink Reply by Jessica on -
Edward, Because he missed her the whole time and his heart was like torn. And he came back sorta looking worried. But Jacob was all kissing and going out will Bella. He had it loads easier.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Alli on -
Jacob. He totally had it harder because he was falling in love with Bella, and then she went and saved Edward and that totally changed Everything.
-
-
Permalink Reply by ninetayala on -
edward because he thought bella was dead so he went to the volturi and ask to kill him but they didnt so he tried to expose himself to the humans for the volturi to kill him and jaocb he sounded so sad when bella left to save edward imagine him in the movie he looked like he was about to cry! when he was a wolf!
-
-
Permalink Reply by CRUOR LUNA COVEN on -
I think Jacob personally. Having to watch the only one you love being owned by someone else must feel like each of your muscles being pulled out one by one.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Sara :) on -
IN MY OPINION:
i think in new moon they both had it pretty hard but the fact that edward thought she was dead kinda makes me think he had it harder. cuz if you think about it the whole time he was away he was suffering and then he finds out she is dead.
on the other hand jacob fell in love with her and right when hes about to get her she leaves him for edward.
in my opinion jacob didn't really lose bella until eclipse. if he believed that he has truly lost her then he would not have been fighting for her as hard in eclipse. he would have just let edward have her like he did at the end of eclipse. that is when he truly lost her. and bella kept hurting jacob over and over and over and over and over and over and OVER again!
jacob without a doubt had it harder in eclipse. -
© 2013 Created by Hachette Book Group.
Report an Issue | Guidelines | Report an Issue | Terms of Service
