The Twilight Saga

Edward: who was forced to leave Bella and then believed that she was dead
or
Jacob: who slowly fell in love with Bella and ended up losing her

Views: 39

Replies to This Discussion

definatley had it harder in New Moon. He beleived that he had to leave
her when he wanted to do just the opposite. Then he beleived that
she was dead and he forfeited his desire to live any longer. Of course,
Jake did go through a pretty hardship in Eclipse.
Edward definatley had it harder in New Moon. He beleived that he had to leave
her when he wanted to do just the opposite. Then he beleived that
she was dead and he forfeited his desire to live any longer. Of course,
Jake did go through a pretty hardship in Eclipse.
Jacob. Because he watched Bella love someone else but not Edward who just left and came back to Bella's waiting open arms. Although Jacob found Renesmee he still can't forget what happened. And he was chosen as the best man. Watching the girl he loved be with someone else and marry Edward..
I am Team Edward but I feel that they both had it hard. You cannot compare the pain that they went through. Even thought the circumstances were different it was still painful. Pain is pain no matter how it attacks you. How you are able to deal with that pain is the difference. When it comes to love, you take risks anyway. One more thing, some of you keep making reference to the fact that Jacob did not choice to become a werewolf. You forget that Edward did not choice to be a vampire.

RSS

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service