do you think Jared and Mels love is really that strong?

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Switzerland_Bri on April 25, 2009 at 10:59am

I think they like each other a lot and that they would still be friends if they weren't the last humans on Earth. But I don't think they are truly in love; I just think that maybe it's like a short relationship kinda thing.

Permalink Reply by Wanting-To-Be-A-Cullen on April 26, 2009 at 4:03pm

i agree that it's not like edward and bella, but i think that it still is really strong. at first it seems like they don't really...idk, love each other as much, but still, jared loves mel even though she was "taken"

Permalink Reply by Sibby! on April 30, 2009 at 10:22am

i don't think they fellin love just beacuse they were the only people left on earth..
because in the book somewhere.. melanies says she doesnt want jared to fell llike she likes him just cuz they are the other ppl left on earth.. and jared jus didnt wanna ehem her.. he knew she was a teen.. so they had boundaries..
and ian and wanda's love seems stronger beacuse its talked about the most through the book.. jared and melanies love is jus breifly touched here and there.... but you can tell they love each other.. when melanie was lost.. jared lost it.. he didnt wanna loose her.. its bacuse jared hated the aliens soo much.. thaz why he fliped half the time.. melanie's love for jared was expressed with all those flashes she gave wanda.. i mean .. damn wanda was in love with jared all beacuse of melanies flashes.. thaz how strong the attraction is.. sooo no i dnt think they jus fell in love cuz they were the last ones on earth..

Permalink Reply by Crystal on May 3, 2009 at 9:53pm

Thank you!!! Finally someone gets it lol

Permalink Reply by Jessica Dickinson on August 10, 2010 at 2:13pm

Again... thank you! I mostly hear how people love the relationship between Wanda and Ian so much, but I've gotta tell you, I was always the biggest fan of Jared and Mel!

Permalink Reply by Crystal on May 3, 2009 at 9:52pm

are u serious peeps? i think their love is soooooooo strong!! even stronger than ian and wanda!! like come ondid u even read the book.......did u see how much jared suffered seeing mel with a soul in her?? and too he kissed wanda how many times just to get a little response from mel.....that seems really strong to me...

Permalink Reply by Rohima Bibi on May 6, 2009 at 3:24pm

that is sooooo true! i mean how can Jared love Mel so much if he is kissing Wanda all the time and telling her he loves her aswell

i dont think yuh can love two people at once in a non-platonic way
and he is always looking at her towards the end and Mel is sometimes touching Ian's arm

Permalink Reply by Caiti on May 7, 2009 at 2:25am

I think the Melanie/Jared love is just as strong the Bella/Edward love. I mean the way Jared handels losing Melanie is very similar to the way Bella handels Edward leaving. He dosen't jump off cliffs but his whole existance seems to be centerd around taking care of Jamie, kinda how Bella takes care of Charlie.

Also a couple kisses from Jared brings Melanie from the brink of non-existance to a screaming fury.

Permalink Reply by Alice Sunhome on October 31, 2009 at 3:48pm

Stephenie described it like flames burning when they touched eachother, so I think it was quite strong^^ Like REALLY

Permalink Reply by Leigha on November 1, 2009 at 6:47pm

I think it is strong but if you remember over time they got to know eachother better like Edward and Bella... Edward didn't know much about Bella when he first fell in love with her ( and like-wise with Bella) and thats the same with Jared and Mel

Permalink Reply by denisse on November 1, 2009 at 11:42pm

i think their love was really strong.. at the begining he only kissed her because he hadn't seen a human in a long time but he fell in love after that... and he loved her very much that's why he said "melanie will always be mine and i'll be hers"

Permalink Reply by sara sprouse on August 9, 2010 at 8:48pm

yes jared and Mel love is strong stronger then wanda/Ian think about it Ian was alway worrie that wandawold leave him

and wanda felt felt moreless the same way Mel/Jared been through alot and thier love for each other kept them going

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• 3
• Next ›
• Page