The Twilight Saga

Edward's reaction to a Jacob/Bella relationship.

Before Bella jumped off the cliff in New Moon we know that Edward was going to come back "just to check on her".  

1. How do you think Edward would handle smelling a werewolf on Bella? (Edward promised she would never see him again, is this "cause" to break that promise)
2. Do you still think that Edward could "walk away" if he knew that Bella was "involved" with a werewolf? (Would it matter if it is a friendship involvement or a romantic involvement?) 
--  If he walks away, does he walk away without her ever knowing that he was there? 

3. How do you think that Jacob would react to smelling a vampire "near by", with two situations.
a) He would not know it was Edward (because Jacob has never smelled Edward with his "wolf" nose) but just a random vampire.
b) Just for argument, how do you think it would change if Jacob knew it was Edward he was smelling.


** Let me clarify on Bella's side.  She does not know Edward is "around".  I pictured Edward's "visit" probably be in in the middle of the night while she is sleeping.   But he would still be able to smell werewolf on her clothes, and if he happen to be in her house (like when they did homework) then Edward would be able to smell him around the place.

Views: 10

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by JJ on July 26, 2010 at 11:31pm
I think you are right. I think that Bella would have to be married to Jacob in order for her to stay with Jacob over being with Edward. I do not see her divorcing Jacob for Edward, but anything less of marriage and I think that Bella would take Edward over Jacob.
Permalink Reply by ஐAℓεxyα Wσσdsஐ on July 27, 2010 at 11:21am
OOOOH!!! I like this comment!! Is there a like button anywhere??? LOL.

Anyway, I totally agree with the whole "17 year old kissing a 77 year old" thing. THAT'S JUST GROSS! But I don't think Jake would ever imprint because Nessie was his true soul-mate. You don't have like 5 girls lined up to be your soul-mate. You only have the one. I do like your idea of Edward and Jacob and Bella's daughter. This is just a random thought, but what do you think she would look like? Their daughter, I mean. I already have Bella and Jacb's kids pictured in my mind!! Lol
Permalink Reply by JJ on July 27, 2010 at 1:41pm
We also had a discussion similar to this so I will add the link and you can check it out. It was pretty cool.

What if Jacob and Bella had married and then he imprinted after 50 years of marriage?
http://thetwilightsagacommunity.ning.com/group/theofficialtwilightb...

Not liking Edward going for Jacob and Bella's daughter, that just seems gross. (and yes I think Nessie is sort of gross also)
Permalink Reply by ஐAℓεxyα Wσσdsஐ on July 28, 2010 at 5:43pm
Yeah I agree. But I would rather it be Bella-and-Jacob instead of Bella-and-Edward. As you can see, I'm on Team Jake.
Permalink Reply by JJ on April 28, 2013 at 3:05pm

I can see.  :D 

RSS

© 2013   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service