Why, "It Doesn't Matter" matters so much in the novel "Twilight"

Introduction: Edward's face is a calm mask, as Bella explains to him that Jacob has told her that he (Edward) is a vampire. As his hands tighten on the steering wheel, she explains that she had started researching the topic on her computer. Then she informs him of her epiphany. (An epiphany is a sudden intuitive perception of reality) Bella tells him that she quite her researching as to if he was a vampire, or even what vampires were like, because no matter what she discovered: "It didn't matter!"

When Edward learns of Bella's epiphany and comprehends it's implications, he goes ballistic. Through clenched teeth he asks Bella: "It doesn't matter that I am a monster?"

White Rose discussion question: Understanding the implications of "It doesn't matter!" is key to fully appreciating the novel "Twilight."

Question number 1. How did "It doesn't matter" Affect Bella, Edward, and the story.

Question number 2. Stephanie said that as she wrote "Twilight" she often could see two different story lines emerging, depending on what had happened. If Bella hadn't discovered that Edward was a vampire how do you feel that it would have changed the story.

Extra credit exercise. Stephanie has said "Twilight" is a study of all the different types of love.The following is a study of how people tend to react when they are reminded of, "What really matters."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ht5yucPQtQ4

As always we sincerely look forward to learning your opinion. Yours, Doc B

0 members like this

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by KimmieCullen - Black on August 19, 2010 at 5:07pm

Question number 1. How did "It doesn't matter" Affect Bella, Edward, and the story.

Great question Doc. I think in short, Bella was always a selfless person from the beginning who knew what she wanted and didn't hide her feelings for one second. She gave truth to the saying, 'love conquers all,' and she truly believed in it. Edward on the other hand always thought Bella should be more cautious with her heart and more cautious about her personal safety. To him, being a 'monster' was never a choice, it was forced upon him and although grateful to Carlisle for being there for him, i'm not sure he would've made the choice of his own accord. Edward loves Bella very early on in the saga but he always considered the dangers and tried to protect Bella. The fact that Bella says, 'it doesn't matter,' makes his situation and their situation together seem like childsplay and seem like an easy situation to overcome. It's far from that and Edward wants Bella to understand whaat she is letting herself in for.

Question number 2. Stephanie said that as she wrote "Twilight" she often could see two different story lines emerging, depending on what had happened. If Bella hadn't discovered that Edward was a vampire how do you feel that it would have changed the story.

There wouldn't have really been much of a story. There would always be that threat of her finding out. But i think one of the main focuses in the story is being able to know everything about someone, even the bad stuff, and loving them regardless. I think Bella finding out about Edward was necessary to get many of the hidden messages across. It is so important in the moral journey through the pages of the saga.

Thanks for the great questions Doc. Sorry i've been away so long, i've had serious issues with my internet access. I'm back now though and i've missed my big family on here lots x x

Permalink Reply by ShannonP on August 19, 2010 at 8:44pm

It's so good to see you back Kimmie!

Permalink Reply by KimmieCullen - Black on August 20, 2010 at 8:10pm

Thanks Shannon, it's good to be back. I feel like i need to find my feet again haha!