The Twilight Saga

Aby Estrella
  • 16, Female
Share Twitter

Aby Estrella's Discussions

if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Pinkie May 13. 19 Replies

Just curios if Bella would still bein the life she has right now.

 

Aby Estrella's Page

Latest Activity

Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Okay Infinite Love.  That is fine. I understand.  "
May 13
Infinite Love replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"I do not see it that way. I just simple do not agree with you! Period! You have your own views and I have mine. For you, Bella picking Jacob defeats the purpose of the Saga, for me then dying as you said they would, defeats the purpose. "
May 13
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"InfiniteLove Choosing Jacob defeats the purpose of the saga, period!  So we must get past that point to fairly access the hypothetical and state what you think would happen.  I wrote out I hope clearly what and why I felt as I did.…"
May 13
Infinite Love replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Yes :) I do not agree with the bit where you said they all will die. If that happened, it would defeat the purpose of the saga in my eyes and there would be no Breaking Dawn"
May 13
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Is this in response to me?  If so, which part of what I said is not plausible specifically in what you read in my comment?"
May 13
Infinite Love replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"I do not agree with that point. If Meyer was to follow the plotline if Bella picked Jacob-then it would not make sense for her to kill of Bella, the Cullens and the Wolves in the third book. I do not think Bella would have become a Vampire if she…"
May 13
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Light Actually Bella would have left with the wolves so their scent would have covered over Bella's human scent.  If Jane was going to be that particular about smells then she should have noticed the wolf stench in Eclipse and she did not.…"
May 13
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Actually Bella would have left with the wolves so their scent would have covered over Bella's human scent.  If Jane was going to be that particular about smells then she should have noticed the wolf stench in Eclipse and she did not.…"
May 13
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"No still say they all die.  Vampire senses read far more acute than what you present.  Jane would know Bella was still human and even the direction and how long she left upon her arrival.  This would happen because Jane would want to…"
May 13
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Yes vampire scent and human scent are different, but Bella would have a whole closet of her human scent even if she were currently a vampire.  And considering in this scenario Bella is actually still human, so her human trail would be easy to…"
May 12
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"My understanding is that human and vampire scents differ so if Bella is a vampire, she would not have her human scent. “There’s not enough time to make you helpful, Bella,” she disagreed coolly. “Do you remember…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"I have enjoyed it as well.  As you point out, there would be plenty of Bella's human scent left in her closet that the newborns could be following.  Bree didn't know the identity of who they were following only her scent.…"
May 12
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"I would still have problems with your scenario as there would be no cataylist for being there.  The scent they were to follow was human and not vampire.  If there was no human scent from her clothing to follow, the Volturi would had known…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Exactly! :D  Bella would have been even more of a "newborn" than the newborns and so therefore even more unskilled.  So them being able to overtake her makes sense.   One of the Cullens told Jane (I think it was Edward)…"
May 12
Pinkie replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"“They are different from you?” Edward asked for Sam. Carlisle nodded. “They are all very new — only months old to this life. Children, in a way. They will have no skill or strategy, only brute strength. Tonight their…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"She could have been burned by one of the newborns towards the beginning of the battle.  Who says that the Cullens started all of the fires?   It makes sense that Victoria could have told her army to immediately burn any of the Cullens who…"
May 12

Profile Information

Five Things Everyone Should Know About You?
im a twilight LOVER. definitely TEAM EDWARD.
When Did You First Read Twilight (year) and how many times have you read a Twilight Book (total)?
2008. i've read all four books.
Team Edward or Team Jacob? Why?
Team Edward, because edward is right for bella, he would sacrifice and do anything for bella. #TEAMEDWARD
Favorite Books
Twilight,Harry Potter.The host,many more
What is Your Favorite Music
All twilight,new moon, eclipse and breaking dawn pt 1&2 soundtracks. Totally
Favorite Movies, TV Shows, Games:
my fav movies are twilight saga,harry potter,snow white
Favorite Quotes:
"No measure of time with you woukd be long enought,but lets start with FOREVER" -EDWARD CULLEN
Favorite Activities
Reading books,magazines and everything about twilight.

Aby Estrella's Blog

What do you think of Stephanies new book?

Posted on February 24, 2013 at 1:34am 6 Comments

Its really nice, i really love it. But twilight is the best book ever.

actually twilight is the first book i read, then i think it was really intersting all the vampire thingy so i decided to read all the book of twilight.

really awesome.. i hope theres more!

How old is renesmee?

Posted on January 15, 2013 at 6:37am 0 Comments

like how is she??????????

How can edward be around bella when she's having her monthly period?

Posted on January 15, 2013 at 6:11am 0 Comments

like seriously how can he be around her?

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of The Twilight Saga to add comments!

Join The Twilight Saga

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service