"Again. How it comes that so many people do not realize that Edward is more in NM book than Jacob?
And whole idea of NM book is the fact that Edward&Bella can not be separate, despite their own stupidity."
"I have to say that Eclipse is my favorite out of the Whole Saga-Book/Movie wise.
Breaking Dawn comes second as a book/Film, whilst New Moon and Twilight are not so popular with me.
Especially because in New Moon, I totally disliked Edward due to his…"
"The BD book needed a much better editor and that would have helped a lot. There are so so so many details that are drawn out and built up for complete disappointment.
Examples for better editing.
Bella meeting with the guy to get…"
"I read in Fanpire, a book that attempts to de-mystify the Twilight phenomenon, that most fans of TTS do not like BD simply because Bella isn't really the Bella that most of us have come to know (and hate or love, lol). By the time…"
"IKR! I had expectations for Eclipse, it still made me emotional, but it just didn't have the appeal the book did for some reason. Same with BD, wasn't excited, wasn't dreading either, but it kind of met the mark for me more than…"
"Yes, I have to agree but not only with eclipse. All of the entire movies were highly faithful to the Books. Now I know there was no fight scene at the end of Break Dawn Pt.2 but I think it was ingenius."
"The movie WAS a favorite but has now been (Excuse the pun LOL) Eclipsed by Breaking Dawn. I find myself drawn to the BD movies more than Eclipse now. However, the books? I'm still gaga over Eclipse. It's weird, but, I don't like BD…"
"Eclipse is probably my least favourite of all four books. Edward is insanely controlling and abusive and Bella is full of indecision over who she loves most - all the while, everyone treats her like she is the most important person in the world and…"