The Twilight Saga

Light's Page

Latest Activity

Light replied to Victoria Taylor's discussion Do you think that Jacob was drawn to Bella because of Renesmee?
"How is Edward's statement different than Jacob's statement?  "I'm not going to cut you in half anymore, Bella."  "
May 16
Light replied to Victoria Taylor's discussion Do you think that Jacob was drawn to Bella because of Renesmee?
"I do not find examples of Agape love between Jacob and Bella, but I do find examples of Eros and Philia.   Both Jacob and Bella demonstrate Philia love for each other and acknowledge that love to each other. Most fans of the serious (even…"
May 15
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion What if Bella had picked up the phone instead of Jacob when edward rang in newmoon?
"I find it very strange that you are telling me what I believe, I haven't had that happen before and not sure how to reply.   My thoughts on suicide were left incomplete and I gave the reason I decided to not continue on that example.…"
May 15
Light replied to Victoria Taylor's discussion Do you think that Jacob was drawn to Bella because of Renesmee?
"I didn't realize that I was saying anything that was challenging when it comes to your views on love.  I acknowledged the four type of love in Greek and clarified that 1 Cor 13 indicates agape love.  That isn't a…"
May 14
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion What if Bella had picked up the phone instead of Jacob when edward rang in newmoon?
"I would rather not go any further on the topic of suicide due to it being a very sensitive subject.  To an individual who has experienced suicide from a loved one my opinions of suicide would be offensive so out of respect for those individuals…"
May 13
Light replied to Victoria Taylor's discussion Do you think that Jacob was drawn to Bella because of Renesmee?
"First off I apologize because I didn't realize that it was too personal (crossing a line) for you to talk about love.  I find your defensiveness to be rather shocking.  Secondly, how is the discussion on the topic of love not…"
May 13
Light replied to Victoria Taylor's discussion Do you think that Jacob was drawn to Bella because of Renesmee?
"In Greek there are four different words that we translate LOVE.  The words for love are: i. Eros was one word for love. It described, as we might guess from the word itself, erotic love. It refers to sexual…"
May 13
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion What if Bella had picked up the phone instead of Jacob when edward rang in newmoon?
"No hard feelings about the other thread, the repeated challenges seemed ironic but they were thought provoking and interesting.  No I wouldn't mean to appear general about a topic as complex as suicide.  There is nothing general…"
May 13
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion vampire tears?
"I don't see any reason why Ms. Meyers could not have used a form of venom for them to cry emotionally. "
May 13
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Actually Bella would have left with the wolves so their scent would have covered over Bella's human scent.  If Jane was going to be that particular about smells then she should have noticed the wolf stench in Eclipse and she did not.…"
May 13
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion What if Bella had picked up the phone instead of Jacob when edward rang in newmoon?
"I'm not really sure what you mean.  It is a rather large middle part of the book where Edward is clearly absent.   The comment about Jacob is also confusing because I don't see what his presence has to do with Edward's…"
May 13
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Yes vampire scent and human scent are different, but Bella would have a whole closet of her human scent even if she were currently a vampire.  And considering in this scenario Bella is actually still human, so her human trail would be easy to…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"I have enjoyed it as well.  As you point out, there would be plenty of Bella's human scent left in her closet that the newborns could be following.  Bree didn't know the identity of who they were following only her scent.…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"Exactly! :D  Bella would have been even more of a "newborn" than the newborns and so therefore even more unskilled.  So them being able to overtake her makes sense.   One of the Cullens told Jane (I think it was Edward)…"
May 12
Light replied to Julia Balthazar Cullen's discussion What if Bella had picked up the phone instead of Jacob when edward rang in newmoon?
"New Moon examples are harder to come by because Edward is gone for most of the book.   Example: Edward's decision to leave without telling Bella the truth.  A mature man trusts his partner with the truth.  Example: His decision…"
May 12
Light replied to Aby Estrella's discussion if bella chose jacob instead of edward,what do you think would happen to edward right now?
"She could have been burned by one of the newborns towards the beginning of the battle.  Who says that the Cullens started all of the fires?   It makes sense that Victoria could have told her army to immediately burn any of the Cullens who…"
May 12

Profile Information

Five Things Everyone Should Know About You?
I am a mother and grandmother
I read the books because of my daughter in law
When Did You First Read Twilight (year) and how many times have you read a Twilight Book (total)?
I don't remember. I have read them all once.
Which Character Are You Most Like?
Alice.
What is Your Favorite Music
Christian

Comment Wall (1 comment)

You need to be a member of The Twilight Saga to add comments!

Join The Twilight Saga

At 6:52pm on March 22, 2014, Donna the OlderWoman said…

Hello Light, Welcome to the OlderWomanGroup!

 
 
 

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service