The Twilight Saga

Many people have beensaying that they dislike Renesmee, but I do not agree. If Nessie wasn't there who (romance wise) would Jake have. Think about that.....

Views: 21

Comment

You need to be a member of The Twilight Saga to add comments!

Join The Twilight Saga

Comment by Rosalie Hale Cullen on February 12, 2009 at 1:08pm
Renesmee is the cutest thing! She's adorable, and come on people, is Edward's baby!!! I mean, she's the reason of why the story ends so perfectly, if not Jake would have always been trying to have Bella away from Edward, with Renesmee, everyone is now in calm and perfection. Honestly I couldn't have thought of a more perfect ending than what Stephenie thought, She's brilliant!
Comment by Kelsey on February 11, 2009 at 4:52pm
omg, I don't know why people don't like renesmee... ): she's such a good character in the book, and such a great addition. I mean, if it wasn't for nessie, than jacob would always be head over heels for bella, and it could never have worked out happily for everyone. and now, bella and jacob get to spend a lot of time together (and like how bella always said she wanted it to just be a simple friendship with her and jacob, like how they used to go into his garage and drink the warm soda out of the bag) and now they can truly be JUST friends, and not have to be awkward anymore. I think that nessie was the best adition to the story, because also, bella and edward get a child, and I think that like what edward had said, that bella was going to miss being able to have kids when she became a vampire, but now she won't EVER have to worry about that, or feel upset about that, because she has renesmee. (: and rosalie gets to have an actual child around for awhile, and so doesn't esme, and they both REALLY wanted one for a long time. and it just works out everything so perfectly. I love how stephenie meyer put nessie into the story, and I hope that sometime she writes more stories about all of the cullens and werewolves, but everyone must understand that jacob and nessie's story is going to end sadly, because jacob can't live forever... ):

ok, one last thing. this is getting long, I know, but I was thinking:

ok, so say that stephenie DID write another book telling about how everyone was doing... ok, so say she speeds ahead in time, like WAYYYY ahead in time, and jacob dies because he can't live forever. I know, I know... sad though. but then, if renesmee was as in love with jacob as bella is in love with edward, wouldn't renesmee try to get herself killed, and then if someone stopped her (say her family) then wouldn't she just be as depressed, if not more, as bella was when edward left her in new moon?? well, she'd actually probably be MORE depressed, because jacob was gone forever, but with bella and edward's cause, bella still had the happiness of knowing that edward was still alive, what she still wanted for him. and then if renesmee did manage to get herself killed, because no one could stop her in time, and alice couldn't see her visions because she can't see "half breeds" as she calls them, then no one would know what renesmee was up to. and then bella and edward would be in so much grief that their only daughter (the only one they'd ever have) was dead, and they'd probably somehow kill themselves too, or just never be happy again. and think about what bella would do when jacob died... I don't think that stephenie should write another book after breaking dawn, unless she somehow makes it so that werewolves are immortal, because I'm sad to say, whatever book would come after breaking dawn would be the saddest one. even more sad than new moon.

ok, yeah, so that's my insight on everything... haha sorry it's so long.
Comment by edwardlovetwilighter on February 11, 2009 at 3:13pm
i like renesmee! jacob can now stop loving bella so now she can love edward more:D....lol
but ya renesmee is adorable (in my mind) and i dont kno how anyone can hate her!
Comment by CatCullen on February 11, 2009 at 2:24pm
I love it that Nessie was brought into the story...i really don't like Jacob too much, but he's a big character in the story and i kind of did feel bad for him (not getting to be with the person he thought he loved) so i'm glad he ended up imprinting on Nessie, that way he's still in Bella's life.
Comment by Alexis Cullen on February 11, 2009 at 2:18pm
Jacob could have me!!! lol
Comment by Alice on February 11, 2009 at 1:46am
Oh, I love Nessie! I don't see why people hate her. If Nessie weren't there, Jacob would be all gloom and doom. The only thing thats creepy is that he made out with his future girlfriend's mom. Well, it is sort of a conflicted story in general, what with Edward's Romantic stalkerness so I guess its okay...But anyways, I love Nessie!
Comment by ღ♠נα∂ε gяεεη♠ღ™ on February 11, 2009 at 1:14am
Yeah...it would've been really messed up if Jacob was left with no one...he'd probably still be all gaga over Bella and then they would probably be at war with the werewolves because Renesmee's the reason why that whole conflict was erradicated...but hey I could be wrong...Stephenie could have probably made Jacob imprint with someone else but where's the fun in that?? Renesmee was a pretty cool twist in Bella's life and I totally did not see that one coming...so I doubt the story could have been made any better.
Comment by Shayy on February 10, 2009 at 9:36pm
I adore Renesmee. She seems absolutely perfet, you know? And cuuute. :] But I dont think that Jake would've been all alone if she didnt exist, though. He eprobably would've somehow gotten over bella after a long time and probably been with leah.
Comment by Katie on February 10, 2009 at 8:54pm
It would probably be a REALLY sad book. Bella and Edward go off happy and cherful. What does Jale get? Running in wolf form, despair maybe...suside. Believe me, I don't want that! Plus, Nessie makes the key problem in the book. Without her, the story would probably be short, and a little boring.
Comment by Sady<3 on February 10, 2009 at 7:30pm
okay this is how i see it;
bella, edward, or jacob never expected there to be a renesmee. none of them knew that was what the future was going to hold. bella was never the "love of his life" it was renesmee all along. he only truly needed bella because she was going to give birth to renesmee. don't get me wrong, i adore jacob, thats just how I see it. [:

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service