The Twilight Saga

Mandy's Comments

Comment Wall (241 comments)

You need to be a member of The Twilight Saga to add comments!

Join The Twilight Saga

At 8:26pm on November 3, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think Rosalie might have not been so bitter if she had children. I mean once Bella has Renesmee and helps Bella care for her she kinda starts to become a nice person. I mean I liked the change and liked her better as a person. I think that Rosalie would have been a great mom and Emmett would be cool as a dad. I'm not as sure with Alice and Jasper. I think that Alice would have been great as a mother but I just don't know how Jasper would be. He always seems so tense that it is hard to tell and in the books it never mentions that he holds Renesmee (or at least what I remember). Still I think that both couples would have been great parents!

Do you think that the Cullens should have been able to keep Bree and teach her the right way instead of having the Volturi kill her?
At 10:19pm on November 2, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
I think Jacob is great! In the book I do like him and feel that we got to know him better in New Moon, but there were times in the books that Jake did get on my nerves!!! In Eclipse when he kissed Bella, I want to jump into that book and slap him around so much!!! Still even if I was mad at what he said or did I still liked him because of how great a friend he was to Bella and how he would do anything to protect her and her family. I mean he eventually came around and was friends, at least as friendly as he could be, with Edward and all the Cullens. He is like that one friend that we all have in our lives knowing that they make us upset at times but still you love them so much you can't stay mad for long and are soon telling them you’re sorry and are great friends again and laughing about what has just happened. So I do love him even if he makes me mad, but only as friends and nothing more.

Well did you ever wish that Rosalie and Emmett or Alice and Jasper could have their own children? If you did how do you think they would have been as parents?
At 3:18pm on October 31, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think that they felt that it wasn't a possibility. I mean they never realized that it was possible with Edward being a vampire and all. I mean Bella never seemed to have becoming a mother anywhere on her lists of wants. This was something that even Edward worried about because he felt he was taking this opportunity always from her. Still I think that Bella was always prepared to be a mother. She was already taking care of her mom before she moved to Forks and this made her seem more to the parental figure that Renee was. Even though she had a child at such a young age she, in my opinion, was ready and was so much more mature for her age than most kids her age are. Some kids her age would get pregnant and rely on their parents to raise their child while they go out and party, but Bella has such wonderful support in her family but she and Edward are the ones that raise Renesmee and they don't like relying on their family to raise her.

What do you think about Jacob in the books do you like him or no?
At 11:48am on October 31, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
For the movie I think that it was great, but I would have liked to see Bella reaction to blood. Throughout the entire saga Bella can't stand the sight of blood and describes the smell of it as a rust like smell. I think this is important because by Breaking Dawn she as to drink the blood to help the baby during her pregnancy and she tells the family that she likes the smell and even that it tastes good. For me I think that is the only part I would want to be included. Other than that I think the movie was great and beautifully done given the budget Catherine was given.

Do you think Bella and Edward should have had a baby so soon after they got married since they were so young and had just gotten married?
At 10:01am on October 29, 2009, Indraraaarrrhhh said…
hi =] oh jeez i absolutley love your shirt!! i wish i had one, its amazing!! <3 and btw just thought id tell you, im stealing some of your quotes cause theyre great ones ;)
At 9:32pm on October 28, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I'm not sure that I would change anything about Edward or Bella. I think that they are perfectly written!! I can totally relate to Bella's personality and clumsiness and I think that's what makes them great. Everyone can relate to at least one of the many characters and for many that's Bella and then with Edward he is the ideal guy that every girl dreams of finding. He has such a sweet, protective, always be there for you personality and has this undying love for Bella. Every girls dreams of finding a guy where they would be protective of you, but not overly protective and also be sweet and understanding of your feelings and then have this love that is hopelessly and undyingly devoted to you. So I think that I would keep them as they are written.

If you could change any one thing about the twilight movie what would it be? It could be a small detail or big one....=)
At 9:59pm on October 27, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Umm.. If I had to date one of the werewolves I would choose either Jacob or Seth. Seth is really sweet and is still able to be friend with all the Cullens even though they are supposed to be like enemies with each other. Then Jacob is always there when you need him. I mean he protects Bella even when Sam didn't want him to be patrolling around Bella's house. He is a great friend and tells you like it is, he holds nothing back! I love that about him. They are both great so I would have to choose between Seth and Jacob.

If you could change anything about Edward or Bella what would you change?
At 9:30pm on October 27, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Yeah I guess so...Well my favorite part of Breaking Dawn… umm… that’s hard because there are so many great parts. I loved Edward and Bella’s wedding, Isle Esme, Bella realizing that she was pregnant, when Edward heard the baby’s thoughts and fell in love with the baby, Jacob becoming Alpha, Seth and Leah joining Jacob’s pack, Bella and Emmett arm wrestling, Renesmee laughing at Bella chopping the rock to dust, Renesmee being born, Bella’s first hunt, Edward and Bella’s cottage, Bella discovering her powers, the werewolves and vampires coming together to save Renesmee, and the end when Bella shows Edward what she is thinking and letting him know that no one has ever loved anyone as much as she loves him. I also liked reading about Charlie meeting Renesmee, that part was so sweet.

If you had to date one of the werewolves, who would it be & why?
At 8:23pm on October 27, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well my favorite part of Eclipse… that’s hard because I liked a lot of different things. I loved hearing about Jasper and Rosalie’s stories on how they were changed; I loved when Alice kidnapped Bella. I didn’t like that Edward went to such extremes when he was away but I understand. I loved when Bella called Jacob to cancel their plans and then she left Edward a message saying that angry grizzly bears were going to seem tame to what was waiting for him at home. I did think that it was sweet that Edward bought a bed for her but I was also thinking just like Bella with it being totally unnecessary!! I loved when Edward proposed to Bella and she finally accepted!! I thought that his proposal was really sweet!! There are more but I don’t think that you want to be reading this for hours!!

What was your favorite part of Breaking Dawn?
At 10:27pm on October 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well at first I thought that it was creepy but then I thought it was really sweet! I mean it was like he was protecting her even before she knew he was. Then I sat there thinking and wishing that I would have someone would watch me while I slept. Not like in a creepy perverted way but like the way Edward was when he watched Bella and spent the night with her. He just wanted to be by her and protect her in anyway that he could.

What was your favorite part of Eclipse?
At 10:11pm on October 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Yes I do think that. I'm not sure if it was love at first sight though, but I like to think it was. I mean with her blood basically singing to him, he had to try so hard just to keep himself in control and not killing her right away. I do think that he became interested in Bella because he couldn't understand why he couldn't hear her thoughts. But yeah I do think that he has loved her since the beginning of the saga. It was almost like once he saw her and everything he realized he found his soul mate. Also the way he protects Bella all the time is just further proof of his love for her. I mean he left her in New Moon because he thought he was protecting her. He still loved her and didn't really want to leave, but did it to protect her. I mean there is proof of his love for Bella in every book, but if I went through it all you would be reading this for a long time.
Do you think it was creepy or sweet that Edward watched Bella sleep for months with out her knowing in the beginning?
At 9:52pm on October 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
I would choose to go to Isle Esme or Forks. Isle Esme just seems so peaceful and romantic. I would just love to go there and feel disconnected from the world. Forks just seems like a great place and I would love to visit there someday. I would also want to visit La Push and Voltura, but Isle Esme and Forks are at the top of my list!!!

Do you think Edward loved Bella from the beginning why or why not?
At 9:37pm on October 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think that I would have reacted the same way Bella did. I certainly would have gone into a depression like phase but still would have put a show on for my family so they felt I was dealing with things. I would have found something to occupy my mind whenever I could because my mind would go to think about Edward so spending as much time with my BFF is a necessary!!!! Yes, because Edward is Bella's one true love I would have done the same thing in forgiving him right away. I still would fear that I would never be enough for him and that he would leave me again, but I would still trust him with my heart all over again.

If you could go to one place that was mentioned in the Twilight Saga which would it be?
At 8:05pm on October 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
I'm not really sure because there are so many great adventures!!! I would love to have experienced the new born vamp fight and to watch Jacob turn into a werewolf but I think that getting to experience everything that happens is Breaking Dawn would be my pick. You have the Volturi, Isle Esme, Renesmee being born and the fight for the Cullens existence.

If you were in Bella's place at the moment that Edward left you, how would have dealt with it? Would you have forgiven him so instantaneously?
At 10:22am on October 25, 2009, iTwilight<3 said…
HEYYY! i haven't talked to you in a whilee :( how are youuu?
At 11:40am on October 24, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
NO, I just think that Bryce is going to screw the role up!!! She just doesn’t seem to know the character as well and just might not do a good job. She already doesn’t seem to have that bad ass feel that Rachelle gave Victoria’s character.

Yeah I don't know if it is official either...I think that Ryan would do a great job as Garrett!! He would do a fantastic job in that role! I just love how versatile he is. He is such an awesome actor and I loved him in Adventureland! I mean I can totally see him as Garrett. I never pictured Garrett much younger I mean with Riley yes but I think that I pictured Garrett in his late 20s to mid 30s so I think that Ryan would be perfect! I hope that they do sign him for the movie!!!!

If you could choose any Twilight Saga adventure to experience first hand...which would it be? Why?
At 8:11pm on October 23, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
I really like Jacob and Seth the most because they are both loyal and don't care about the vampires. I mean Jacob thought that he could be friends with Bella once she was changed but he still was and just didn't let it affect their friendship. So yeah I would choose Jacob and Seth.

Did you hear that Ryan Reynolds might play the role of Garrett in Breaking Dawn?
At 9:02pm on October 22, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I would change Breaking Dawn mostly. I would have loved to hear what Bella was thinking throughout the entire pregnancy and not Jacob's point of view. I would also have more of a closure to the series because it just leaves you with so many unanswered questions, did the Volturi ever come back to check on Bella and Renesmee's progress, how did Jacob and Renesmee's relationship develop after the series ended, and Bella and Edward's relationship. I would have just loved if the series had continued!! I mean if not from Bella's point of view than possibly Renesmee's that way we can still have the Cullens and the wolf pack.

So which werewolf do you like best and why?
At 9:07pm on October 20, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Yeah I do agree with you although I am still Team Switzerland...LOL!

Yeah I know, I think either Sam or Jacob would have to be my least favorite! I mean Sam just doesn't think about the consequences of his actions and I hated that he wanted to kill Bella and basically didn't even bat an eyelash about it. I don't like Jacob because in the same way he is a little controlling of Bella and keeps trying to get Bella away from Edward and wants to kill Edward so badly! But at the same time he is still a good friend to Bella and wouldn't do anything to hurt her.

If you can change something in Twilight saga what it will be?
At 10:33pm on October 19, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well that's hard because I love all the books each for different reasons, but I think that my favorite would have to be either Twilight or Breaking Dawn. Twilight because this is where Bella and Edward fall in love and it is just awwww!!! I like Breaking Dawn because this is where Bella and Edward finally get their happily ever after and they get to start their own family and Bella finally becomes like Edward. Yeah I know! Each book is so good in its own way!! I mean I say that Twilight and Breaking Dawn are my favorites, but I love New Moon because of all the action (especially Voltura!!). I also like New Moon because of how emotionally attached I was with it. I mean I cried and everything and when reading it I felt as if I was in that pit of depression with Bella. This book has to be the lowest point in the entire saga and then you come to the end and you have an incredible rush of adrenaline with Bella trying to save Edward and then meeting the Volturi. New Moon just holds a special place in my heart because of how emotionally effected I was when reading it. With Eclipse for the whole "new born vamp fight" and Bella slapping Jacob and more!! I understand it is SO hard to choose a favorite!!


So who is your least favorite character and why?

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service