The Twilight Saga

Mandy's Comments

Comment Wall (241 comments)

You need to be a member of The Twilight Saga to add comments!

Join The Twilight Saga

At 4:32pm on February 10, 2010, Tiffany said…
Hey how are you doing?
At 4:57pm on January 19, 2010, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think the one to fit their character best would be Peter as Carlisle. I mean you always hear the cast talking about getting together at his house for game and dinner nights. They even call him Dad in public. It is like he is always there to help any of them if they need it. Some others that I think fit their roles in real life are Ashley and Elizabeth and maybe even Kellan. Ashley is always bubbly and has a smile on her face where ever she goes, Elizabeth seems like the motherly type always watching out for the cast and wanting what is best for them. I mean she went and meet Rob in NYC while he was filming Remember Me and talked to Emile about kissing him and everything. Kellan seems like he fits his role in real life too with how funny he is and is always working out and stuff. LOL!! To me those are the people to fit their roles in real life the most!! How about you, what do you think?

If you were in Bella’s place right after she was transformed into a newborn, do you think that you would get creeped out by how fast Renesmee was growing?
At 4:46pm on January 19, 2010, Bella Swan-Blake said…
No I totally understand...you are fine!!

If I was Bella and Edward didn't want to turn me, I would probably see if Alice or someone else would change me. But I think I would try to convince Edward t change me especially if he was the one that I wanted to turn me.

Who out of the cast, do you think fits their characters best in real life? (Example Kristen fits her character Bella in real life because…)
At 4:54pm on December 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
WOW, that's really hard!!! I mean each book has a purpose in the saga and gives Bella and Edward's relationship to new levels. I think that it would depend on the day and the mood I was in, but right now Eclipse keeps popping into my mind so today I say Eclipse. I just love that you have both the vamps and werewolves in it. You also have Edward and Bella being jealous and other stuff too.

If you were Bella and Edward didn't want turn you, What would you do?
At 4:42pm on December 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I’m not sure about the director but I think I would love it if Catherine would come back or if for the last film all directors team up. So I’m not real sure about the director, but my dream cats would be as follows:


Bella- Kristen Stewart
Edward- Rob Pattinson
Renesmee- Catherine Grimme
Alice- Ashley Greene
Jasper- Jackson Rathbone
Rosalie- Nikki Reed
Emmett- Kellan Lutz
Carlisle- Peter Facinelli
Esme- Elizabeth Reaser
Charlie- Billy Burke
Renee- Sarah Clarke
Angela- Christian Serratos
Ben- Aaron Yoo
Jessica- Anna Kendrick
Mike- Michael Welch
Eric- Justin Chon
Garrett- Ryan Reynolds
Jacob- Taylor Lautner
Sam- Chaske Spencer
Seth- BooBoo Stewart
Leah- Julia Jones
Billy- Gil Birmingham
Quil- Tyson Houseman
Embry- Kiowa Gordan
Emily- Tinsel Korey
Jane- Dakota Fanning
Alec- Cameron Bright
Casius- Jamie Campbell-Bower
Aro- Michael Sheen
Maricus- Christopher Heyerdahl
Felix- Daniel Cudmore
Demetri- Charlie Bewley
Kate- Jena Malone
Irina- Katie Powers
Tanya- Amanda Bynes (?)
Peter- Gavin Bristol
J. Jenks- Wallace Shawn
Charlotte- Jenna Dewan
Renata- Briana Evigan

If Stephenie Meyers had only put out one book in the series which one would you choice for her to put out and why?
At 10:24am on December 26, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Thanks hope that You had a great Christmas and will have a happy New Year!!

Well I'm sure that there were times that other people's blood did sing to him but Bella's blood was just so much more pronounced then others that he was never affected like the Volturi describes the reaction to a singer's blood. I think that if Edward had meet Bella in his younger vampire years that he probably would have sucked her dry but with Carlisle's training he was able to resist Bella's blood and didn't even realize that Bella was his singer till the Volturi told him about it. I do think that Bella's blood singing to him did attract him a bit more to Bella, but it was like they were long lost soul mates that had found each other after so many years. I just don't think that anyone had ever caught Edward's interest till Bella and the fact the she was his singer and he couldn't read her mind I think attracted him more to her.

Ok here’s a new question…with the upcoming film of Breaking Dawn, who is your dream director and cast for the movie?
At 6:23pm on December 25, 2009, Tiffany said…
At 1:56pm on December 24, 2009, Jaspers#1Fan said…
o.k. thanks!
i took this computer applications class this last semester and i learned how to do alot of cool stuff so i made my own movie poster with the alice and jasper picture and i put new moon on that one and i was going to put the other movies on the other three pictures, and hang them up with all my other twilight saga posters!
So that is why i was just trying to find the rest of the pictures so if you find them that would be great but if you don't that is o.k. too!
At 11:44am on December 22, 2009, Jaspers#1Fan said…

hey do you have the pics that look like this but have bella and edward, rosalie and emmet, and carlile and esme on them?
At 10:12pm on December 15, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
No, I think that Jacob just basically forced himself on her. He did fall in love with Bella and I think he thought that he would be able to ease himself into Edward’s spot since he left, but with Bella and Alice going to Italy to rescue Edward he just reacted so territorial and wanted to prove himself to Bella. He was all macho in Eclipse like he was some big bad ass and was so immature!!! He sould have been able to see with how much pain Bella was in after New Moon that she would always love Edward no matter what. She may have been able to move on but she would never be truly happy. I know that he wanted to prove that he was the better choice and he told Bella that he would never hurt her, but he did really. With him telling Bella she had to choose a side and the games he would play with Bella’s emotions was just uncalled for. I just think that he could have found a better way to prove himself to Bella then how he went about it.

Edward said that Bella was his singer and he ended up falling in love with her and they became soul mates. Well do you think someone’s blood had to sing to Edward for him to fall in love or do you think he just choose to be alone and not fall in love with anyone before Bella?
At 9:59pm on December 15, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
For me, it only reinforced it. I do think that the books were better but they have more detail then the movies could have fit in. Still the movies were great too, so I really loved having the movie and it didn’t hurt my love for the saga one bit.

Do you agree with Jacob in eclipse, when he's pushing Bella to choose him even if he knows how devastated she was when Edward was gone?
At 7:08pm on December 15, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think that Bryce just might not do as well as Rachelle would have with portraying Victoria’s character. She just doesn’t seem to know the character as well and just might not do a good job. She already doesn’t seem to have that bad ass feel that Rachelle gave Victoria’s character. I think that everyone else will do a good job, but we will have to wait and see.

Did Twilight the movie reinforce or hurt your love for the book?
At 7:10pm on December 10, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I hope that they will have the background stories for both Rosalie and Jasper, Jacob kissing Bella and then Bella punching him, Alice kidnapping Bella and spending the night at the Cullen house, Bella’s phone call to Edward while she is there about how much trouble he is in, Bella sleeping on the couch only to wake up to Edward, the whole compromise discussion about marriage, college and Bella being turned. There is just so much that I hope that they have in the movie but these are the main ones I would like to see.

What scenes do you think the actors might or will butcher?
At 10:48pm on December 9, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I like the way they look in both New Moon and Twilight. I do think though that the characters appearances will fit more in New Moon than in Twilight because of the movie budget increase, but either way they look great in both of them. Ok that one's hard I think with the color scheme of the movie the werewolves’ pop out to the eyes more than the vampires but they both look great!!

What quotes/scenes would you like to see in the movie Eclipse?
At 10:38pm on December 9, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Yes and No, I mean I liked getting in Jacob's head and seeing things from his POV. I liked seeing how that pack life really was but with Bella being pregnant I had really wanted to hear the entire thing from her POV. I mean I'm not really upset that we don't hear everything from her POV but I still would have liked it. I liked hearing how he felt about everything from the pack to imprinting to all the Cullens and what Bella was doing with her life.

So do you like the way the characters look better in twilight or new moon. And who do you think is better looking in new moon the wolves or the vampires?
At 3:15pm on December 6, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think everything in the saga was great!! But if there is one thing that I think should have been left out it would have been that there was no fight with the Volturi in Breaking Dawn. I mean we are all lead and amped up for such a huge fight with the Volturi and nothing. I’m not complaining because I’m glad that the Cullens weren’t killed but I wish that they had maybe convinced the onlookers of the Volturi’s misuse of their power and there had been some sort of revolt where the Volturi were replaced or dismissed. Just something that had happened other than nothing.

Did you like in Breaking Dawn where she told book two through Jacob’s point of view?
At 9:38pm on December 3, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
I do think that Alice never had a vision of Bella moving to Forks or meeting Edward and spending their life together. I think that if Alice did have a vision that she would have been able to see Bella and Edward fall in love, but that she wouldn’t know exactly who Bella was or when Edward would meet her. She also wouldn’t have seen Edward and Bella life together as vampires and having a family and all. I mean my basic idea of her vision is the meadow scene from the Twilight movie to the point that they are sitting and talking on the grass and then lying down and just staring lovingly into each others eyes. To me that scene is just so self explanatory of their love for one and other as well as their relationship at that point.

If there’s one thing in the whole saga that you think Stephenie Meyers should have left out what would it have been?
At 10:43pm on November 30, 2009, Bella Swan-Blake said…
Well I think that Bella’s power would have been just her self-control. I mean she had such self control after being born as a vampire that it was like she surpassed several new born years that all the Cullens and Bella were prepared for. Yes it may have just been that with how much time Bella spent with the Cullens had prepared her for this life that she was having her “newborn years” while she was human, but I still think that it was a special power of hers. I mean she was able to restrain herself from attacking innocent humans when she smelled her blood even though the fire in her throat told her to suck them dry. So that’s what I think her power would have been and I don’t think that Edward being unable to read her mind should be tied into her power.

Alice says she never "saw" Bella in Edward's future/saw her at all before Forks, that she never even had a premonition of Edward ever having a mate, etc -- do you agree with this or do you think Stephenie was just being lazy? If Alice were to have seen Bella in a vision before she (Bella) met Edward, what would that vision be of and do you think she would tell Edward about this vision?
At 7:58pm on November 29, 2009, ♫ çëяÔ żαяαн™ ϟ тhε кillэясiттα said…
ok!! you are a really fan of twilight!!
At 3:53pm on November 28, 2009, iTwilight<3 said…
Heeeyy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I haven't been on in a long time :(
Did you see NEW MOON?!!!!!!

© 2014   Created by Hachette Book Group.

Report an Issue | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service